This Tweet came across my feed earlier today. Leaving aside both the bad-faith argument and the level of sheer bufoonery on display, I thought it deserved an honest response. Not so much for Mr. Black's benefit, since people who pose such questions are never looking for understanding. Rather, this post is meant as a rally point. Something those on the right can point to next time some dumbass makes a comment like Mr. Black's. If culture begins with storytelling, then conservative culture begins with the idea that things like Patriotism and Christianity aren't automatic punchlines or villains. For decades, "subversive" takes on these subjects have been the dominant storytelling mode in Hollywood and Big 5 (now Big 4) publishing. And it's tiresome. There are only so many times an audience is willing to pay good money to see itself and its values mocked. Sooner or later, they want entertainment choices that don't paint them as ignorant, evil, or both. If major media companies can't provide it, they start looking elsewhere. The most comprehensive take on this subject is, of course, Brian Niemeier's book, Don't Give Money to People Who Hate You. I highly recommend it. You might not agree with everything he says, but that doesn't change the fact that he's right. If anything, comments like Mr. Black's only serve to reinforce Brian's message. Black can't conceive of a "conservative culture" that isn't a repressive caricature of Christian values. The conservative worldview is so foreign to him, he literally had to use villains from an 80's movie to make his point. The comments beneath his aren't much better. Several are worse. None of them line up with reality. That said, there is a definite conservative culture, especially in SFF. Most conservatives I know gravitate to fast-paced adventure fiction over deconstruction and subversion. They want to read about people solving problems instead of navel-gazing, and they want strong heroes that reflect their personal values. Here's a partial list of writers who deliver just that: Jon Mollison Jon Del Arroz Brian Niemeier Bradford C. Walker Kit Sun Cheah Schuyler Hernstrom Alexander Hellene Adam Lane Smith JD Cowan TJ Marquis Rawle Nyanzi I'd also be remiss if I didn't mention two excellent publishers: DMR Books and Cirsova Magazine. If any publication can truly be said to have inherited the spirit of Weird Tales and Argosy, it's Cirsova. They specialize in the same kind of fast-paced adventure fiction many of the above writers do. DMR books specializes in classic-style Sword & Sorcery and Sword & Planet. They've released high-quality reprints of Golden Age classics alongside original fiction from modern masters of the craft. Which segues into my next point. Another great pillar of conservative culture--especially in SF and fantasy--is old stories, particularly the pulps. Classic writers like Edgar Rice Burroughs, Robert E. Howard, and H. P. Lovecraft are well known enough to casual genre fans. Their most famous creations are household names even to non-readers. But there are plenty of other, equally important pulp-era writers that have been largely forgotten, writers like Abraham Merritt and Manly Wade Wellman. Conservative culture is also about reading and rediscovering these stories, and keeping them alive for new generations of readers. If you need a roadmap, the two best resources for getting into old stories are The Pulp Archivist, and Jeffro Johnson's Appendix N: The Literary History of Dungeons & Dragons. The Pulp Archivist regularly posts on classic fiction from the Golden Age. Jeffro's book is an excellent primer and overview on the SFF scene as it existed before 1980. As a bonus, you'll also get lots of great insights as to how old pulps and the 1960s-70s SFF scene shaped early Dungeons & Dragons. You want to see what real conservative culture looks like? Follow some of those guys. Better yet, read their books. Read the old ones, too, to see the style of storytelling they want to preserve, and what some of them are writing in conscious tribute to. As for closing the rift in popular culture? That's a much taller order. Honestly, it might not be possible anymore. But if you're serious about it, then step one is to stop treating half the culture like the punchline.
6 Comments
J. Hopewell
12/12/2020 11:34:25 am
Oh, boo hoo. "There are only so many times an audience is willing to pay good money to see itself and its values mocked. Sooner or later, they want entertainment choices that don't paint them as ignorant, evil, or both. If major media companies can't provide it, they start looking elsewhere." This is exactly how lib identitarians defend their critiques of approved media. Black folks, gays, indigenous peoples, women, and the subaltern in general have been portrayed as clowns and villains for years. They have been punchlines for a long time. Buck up! Have you seen old any black and white films? Ever seen how black folks are presented? I'm a conservative policy maker and I don't care for how you speak so ignorantly for my "culture." You're not describing conservative culture. Your sharing a personal opinion, so don't speak like you know all conservatism. You joker poser conservatives don't understand that traditionalist views aren't incommensurate with being kind to people different from you. Best conservative work in the past years has been Clint Eastwood's *Gran Turino.* Watch and unlearn some of that Trumpist, ethnonationalist bullshit you're shoveling. Trumpism has rotted your brains.
Reply
Bowtie Slayer
12/12/2020 11:44:28 pm
The bowtie is spinning so fast we're about to see take-off, folks.
Reply
Fae
12/13/2020 08:32:33 am
Wow. Project much?
Reply
lol
12/15/2020 03:34:36 pm
Nobody cares, loser.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AboutI'm an award-winning science fiction and fantasy writer based out of North Carolina. This is where I scream into the digital void. I like cookies. Archives
December 2020
Categories
All
|